Dow Chemical / Dow Inc. Pension Lump Sum vs. Annuity: A 2026 Guide for Dow Employees
Dow Inc. (formerly The Dow Chemical Company) is one of the largest chemical companies in the world, with approximately 35,000 U.S. employees and a substantial defined-benefit pension program covering current and former employees across its materials science, packaging, and industrial solutions divisions. The Dow Employees' Pension Plan (DEPP) is structured in two distinct components — a traditional pension equity formula and a Personal Pension Account (PPA) — and also covers former employees of Rohm and Haas (acquired 2009) and Union Carbide (acquired 2001) through integrated sub-components. Dow has executed at least one pension risk transfer, buying a group annuity contract from Metropolitan Tower Life Insurance to transfer approximately $700 million in U.S. pension obligations — ending PBGC federal insurance for the affected participant group and shifting their backstop to state insurance guaranty funds.1 For current and former Dow employees evaluating whether to take a lump sum or monthly annuity, these plan mechanics, the interest-rate environment, and the Dow Savings Plan Rule-of-55 trap all shape the decision.
Dow's pension risk transfer to Metropolitan Tower Life: what it means for you
Dow Inc. has executed a pension risk transfer (PRT) — the mechanism by which employers permanently reduce pension balance-sheet risk by purchasing a group annuity contract from an insurance company that then assumes direct responsibility for paying benefits to affected participants.1
The transaction: Dow purchased a group annuity contract from Metropolitan Tower Life Insurance Company, a subsidiary of MetLife, to transfer approximately $700 million in U.S. pension liabilities.1 Participants whose benefits were included in this transfer received written notification from Dow or the insurer. For that participant group:
- Monthly payments continue uninterrupted. Metropolitan Tower Life took over exactly where Dow left off. Payment amounts, survivor elections, and benefit terms did not change at the time of transfer.
- PBGC federal insurance ended entirely. Once pension obligations transfer to an insurance company, the PBGC guarantee — which covers up to $7,789.77/month at age 65 in 20262 — no longer applies. The backstop is now Metropolitan Tower Life's own financial reserves.
- State insurance guaranty funds apply instead. Most states guarantee annuity obligations up to $250,000 per insurer per insured, with some states higher. This is not equivalent to PBGC protection for participants with large monthly benefits.
To put Dow's transfer in context with other major corporate pension risk transfers:
| Employer | PRT amount | Insurer | PBGC protection after transfer |
|---|---|---|---|
| IBM | ~$22B total | Prudential / MetLife | Ended; state guaranty fund |
| AT&T | $8.05B | Athene | Ended; state guaranty fund |
| Verizon | ~$13.4B total | Prudential / RGA | Ended; state guaranty fund |
| Lockheed Martin | ~$9.2B total | Athene | Ended; state guaranty fund |
| RTX / Raytheon | $2.5B | Prudential | Ended; state guaranty fund |
| Dow Inc. | ~$700M | Metropolitan Tower Life | Ended for transferred group; intact for remaining participants |
Participants who were not included in the Metropolitan Tower Life transfer retain their PBGC protection on the remaining benefit. For those participants, the lump-sum decision involves weighing the benefit of keeping PBGC coverage (on benefits up to the $7,789.77/month cap) against the benefit of taking the lump sum and managing it independently.
Dow's pension plan structure: DEPP Component, PPA, Rohm and Haas, and Union Carbide
The Dow Employees' Pension Plan (DEPP) is structured in two distinct components, and not all participants are covered by both:
DEPP Component — traditional pension equity formula
The DEPP Component is a traditional defined-benefit formula. Your benefit is expressed as a monthly annuity based on your pay history and years of service. If you elect a lump sum, the plan converts your monthly annuity to a present value using IRS §417(e)(3) segment rates — the same methodology used by virtually every large corporate defined-benefit plan. Higher segment rates compress the lump sum; lower rates expand it.
PPA Component — Personal Pension Account
The PPA Component is a cash-balance-style account. Rather than a formula-based monthly annuity, the PPA credits your account each year with employer pay credits and interest credits. Your PPA lump sum is effectively your accumulated account balance. If you want monthly income instead of a lump sum, the plan converts your account balance to an annuity using plan-specific actuarial assumptions.
The PPA has a critical distinction from traditional DEPP-formula lump sums: the interest rate assumptions used to calculate PPA amounts are set annually for the January 1 through December 31 period.3 Most large corporate plans use November segment rates — meaning the rates published each November set lump sum offers for the entire following calendar year. Dow's PPA uses a January-through-December lock that means your PPA offer is stable throughout the year but can shift meaningfully between years as interest rate assumptions are reset. In 2025, Dow's PPA interest rate assumptions were lower than 2024 assumptions, which in general produces a larger PPA lump sum — a factor that made 2025 a favorable time window for Rohm and Haas participants offered a lump sum election.
Rohm and Haas legacy participants
Dow acquired Rohm and Haas Company in 2009. The Rohm and Haas Company Retirement Plan was formally merged into the Dow Employees' Pension Plan on December 30, 2015.3 Former Rohm and Haas employees whose pension benefits were part of that plan are now covered as a sub-component within the DEPP, with benefit calculations reflecting their Rohm and Haas service and compensation history.
Union Carbide legacy participants
Dow acquired Union Carbide Corporation in 2001. The Union Carbide Employees' Pension Plan continues to exist as a separate qualified plan for former Union Carbide employees, maintained alongside the DEPP. Former Union Carbide employees should identify which plan covers their benefit — the DEPP or the Union Carbide plan — before modeling lump sum numbers, as plan terms and distribution mechanics may differ.4
The 2025 Rohm and Haas lump sum election window
In 2025, Dow issued special lump sum election notices to two groups of former Rohm and Haas participants within the DEPP:
- Active former Rohm and Haas participants: Current Dow employees who had legacy Rohm and Haas pension benefits were given a one-time election window. The deadline to make an election was August 29, 2025.3
- Deferred vested terminated (DVT) participants: Former Dow/Rohm and Haas employees who left the company before retirement and retained a deferred vested pension benefit also received election notices with a similar window to choose a distribution form.
Three options were available in the election:
- Lump Sum Payment: Receive the full present value of your pension benefit as a single cash distribution or direct rollover to a traditional IRA, Roth IRA, or other eligible retirement plan. A direct rollover avoids the 20% mandatory federal withholding that applies to cash distributions.
- Immediate Monthly Annuity: Begin collecting monthly pension payments immediately, with survivor election options (joint-and-survivor, period-certain).
- Defer Payment Until Later: Leave the benefit in the plan for distribution at a future date, subject to the plan's normal commencement rules.
If you elected the lump sum and received your distribution in late 2025 or early 2026, you are now in the rollover management phase. See the post-rollover strategy section below.
How interest rates affect Dow pension lump sums: the January look-back
For participants in the DEPP Component (traditional pension equity formula), lump sums are calculated using the standard IRS §417(e)(3) three-segment methodology:
- Segment 1 — applies to the first five years of projected annuity payments (near-term cash flows, lowest rate).
- Segment 2 — applies to years 6 through 20 (intermediate-term).
- Segment 3 — applies to years 21 and beyond (long-dated cash flows, highest rate).
Higher rates produce smaller lump sums; lower rates produce larger ones. Most large corporate plans use November's published segment rates to set the following year's lump-sum offers. For reference, the November 2025 segment rates — which set many employers' 2026 lump sum offers — were 4.07% / 5.15% / 6.01%.5 These rates are materially higher than the 2020–2021 near-zero environment, which means lump sums today are smaller relative to annuity benefits than they were five years ago.
For PPA Component participants, the mechanics differ. Dow sets PPA interest rate assumptions on a January 1 through December 31 calendar-year basis.3 This means:
- Your PPA lump sum offer is stable throughout the year — it does not shift month to month as IRS rates are published.
- Rate changes take effect at year-end when Dow resets the annual assumption.
- Unlike November-look-back plans where choosing a December vs. January retirement date can swing the offer by tens of thousands of dollars, Dow PPA participants face a different timing dynamic: the important date is the calendar year, not the month within the year.
In 2025, Dow's PPA interest rate assumptions were lower than 2024 assumptions. In a lower-rate environment, the PPA lump sum is larger — because the conversion of the account balance to an annuity or the present-value calculation runs at a lower discount rate. This favorable rate environment was part of the context for the 2025 Rohm and Haas lump sum election window.
The Dow Savings Plan Rule-of-55 trap
Many Dow employees and retirees have significant balances in the Dow Savings Plan (the company's 401(k)-style defined contribution plan). The Rule of 55 under IRC §72(t)(2)(A)(v) provides a critical but widely misunderstood exception to the 10% early-distribution penalty:
- What it allows: If you separate from Dow in or after the calendar year you turn 55, you can take penalty-free withdrawals from the Dow Savings Plan before age 59½.
- What it does NOT allow: This exception is specific to distributions from the qualified plan where you separated from service. It does not transfer to an IRA. If you roll the Dow Savings Plan balance to an IRA before age 59½, withdrawals from that IRA face the standard 10% early-distribution penalty (unless you set up a 72(t) SEPP or qualify for another exception).
This consideration is separate from the pension lump sum rollover. Rolling your DEPP lump sum to an IRA does not affect the Dow Savings Plan's Rule-of-55 eligibility — the two accounts are tracked separately. The trap occurs only if you also roll the Savings Plan itself to an IRA before 59½.
Lump sum vs. annuity: the Dow-specific decision framework
Dow's pension situation involves several factors that make the standard lump-sum vs. annuity framework more nuanced:
| Factor | Favors lump sum | Favors annuity |
|---|---|---|
| PBGC transfer risk | If your benefit transferred to Metropolitan Tower Life, counterparty exposure makes lump sum + IRA rollover more appealing | Benefits still in the DEPP retain PBGC coverage (up to $7,789.77/mo cap) — a federal backstop the lump sum forfeits |
| Benefit size | Benefits above $7,789.77/mo at 65 have no PBGC backstop anyway; lump sum eliminates insurer risk | Smaller benefits are fully PBGC-covered; guaranteed income is valuable if you lack other fixed income |
| Other income | Strong Social Security, spouse's pension, or rental income covers baseline expenses — the lump sum's investment flexibility adds value | Limited other guaranteed income — the annuity fills the income gap |
| Health / longevity | Below-average life expectancy or family history of early death makes the lump sum more likely to win | Above-average longevity expectation — annuity provides longevity insurance past break-even age |
| Rate environment | Rising rate environment (segment rates going up) compresses future lump sums — taking the lump sum now locks in a higher value | If rates decline further, annuity offer grows in present-value terms; waiting can increase the annuity-implied yield |
| Roth conversion opportunity | Rolling to an IRA enables a 10-15 year Roth conversion window before RMDs begin — significant tax value for large balances | Annuity produces fixed monthly income with no conversion flexibility; RMDs from any rolled IRA still apply to other accounts |
| Heirs / estate | Lump sum leaves remaining balance to heirs; annuity typically ends at death or surviving spouse's death | Period-certain election provides some death benefit; no investment risk for surviving spouse |
Post-rollover IRA strategy for Dow employees
If you took the DEPP lump sum and rolled it to a traditional IRA, the planning work is just beginning:
Investment allocation: the pension-as-bond insight
If you kept a Dow annuity (monthly pension income), a Dow COLA supplement, or have Social Security income, that fixed income functions like a bond in your overall portfolio — it provides stable, predictable cash flow regardless of market conditions. This means your rollover IRA can often carry a higher equity allocation than traditional age-based rules suggest, because your "bond" exposure is already built into your guaranteed income. Many retirees with strong pension income systematically under-invest their rollover IRA.
Roth conversion window: ages 60–72
After rolling the pension lump sum to a traditional IRA, you typically have a window of 10-15 years before required minimum distributions begin at age 73 (born 1951–1959) or 75 (born 1960+) under SECURE 2.0. During this window, strategic annual Roth conversions — filling the 22% or 24% bracket — can materially reduce lifetime taxes and RMDs. The 2026 brackets: 22% bracket tops out at $105,700 (single) or $211,400 (MFJ); 24% bracket tops out at $201,775 (single) or $403,550 (MFJ).6
Convert too aggressively and you push into the 32% or 35% bracket and may trigger IRMAA Medicare surcharges. Convert too conservatively and you leave future RMDs to be taxed at potentially higher rates. An advisor can model the optimal annual conversion target.
IRMAA management
Medicare Part B and Part D surcharges (IRMAA) kick in at $109,000 MAGI (single) or $218,000 (MFJ) in 2026, adding $974–$11,688/year in combined Part B and Part D surcharges for a couple across the five IRMAA tiers.7 Roth conversions, large IRA distributions, or RMDs can push you across IRMAA thresholds. If your pension annuity income is near or above the first IRMAA threshold, plan Roth conversions carefully to avoid compounding surcharges.
The 20% withholding trap
If you elected a cash distribution rather than a direct rollover, the plan is required to withhold 20% for federal income tax. To complete a tax-free rollover you must deposit 100% of the gross distribution (including the withheld 20%) into an IRA within 60 days. You must fund the withheld 20% from other sources. Missed rollovers or partial rollovers are fully taxable in the year of distribution — at ordinary income rates, potentially pushing a large lump sum into the 32–37% bracket. Always use a direct rollover (trustee-to-trustee) to avoid this entirely.
- Dow pension risk transfer to Metropolitan Tower Life: "Dow buys annuity from Metropolitan Tower Life to transfer pension liabilities," Pensions & Investments.
- PBGC maximum guarantee for 2026: PBGC — Your Guaranteed Pension (Single-Employer Plans). Straight-life at age 65: $7,789.77/month.
- Rohm and Haas plan merger date, PPA look-back period, and 2025 election window: Dow Inc. HR documentation — "2025 Active Employee Lump Sum Notice" and "2025 DVT Employee Lump Sum Notice" for former Rohm and Haas Company Retirement Plan participants. Available at corporate.dow.com HR resources.
- Union Carbide Employees' Pension Plan annual funding notices: corporate.dow.com — HR documents, "Annual Funding Notice for Union Carbide Employees' Pension Plan."
- IRS §417(e) minimum present value segment rates — November 2025 (4.07% / 5.15% / 6.01%): IRS Notice 2026-XX; verified via IRS.gov minimum present value segment rates.
- 2026 federal income tax brackets: IRS Rev. Proc. 2025-32.
- 2026 IRMAA thresholds and Part B premium amounts: CMS Medicare & Medicaid Services; base premium $202.90/month in 2026.
Values verified as of October 2026. Tax law and PBGC guarantee amounts adjust annually. Consult your Dow Summary Plan Description and a qualified tax advisor for your specific situation.